A couple of things stuck out when I was reading Chapter 8. First was the commentary about how to advance an argument. After being in the Communcations Department and having the opportunity to judge debates, I feel that she has left out some key aspects of constructing a good argument. Additionally, I really enjoyed her conversation regarding original thought and using everything around you.
Pipher’s view on advancing an argument has some very good aspects while also leaving out key components. I completely agree that our personal experience will affect how we view the world. Also, this personal experience will inevitably draw us closer to the audience. Throughout the recent presidential debates, Hillary Clinton has been criticized for being too mechanical and stand-offish – much like Al Gore.
However, Pipher fails to mention having credible sources and evidence to support your opinion. She briefly mentions the importance of being precise when discussing facts, yet facts should always be intertwined throughout the entire argument. In addition, a writer or speaker must construct a strong foundation by clarifying vocabulary. It is essential that everybody participating within the argument know exactly what is being discussed. Finally, whenever a person is arguing something a solution must be offered. It makes no sense to say this is the problem, life sucks, pity me. Overall, I do not disagree with Pipher’s viewpoint, but rather believe she needs to include other key components. Preparing for a debate entails much more than simply telling the audience why and how you’ve arrived at this conclusion.
Next, I completely agree with Pipher when she talks about using original thought, which ultimately comes from being observant of the environment. I know from my current experience with the Philosophy Department that creativity and innovative thoughts are highly valued. One of the basic criteria for undergraduate philosophers wanting to become published is original thought. In all reality, this was probably the most deciding factor when I was evaluating submissions. Original thought only comes from taking a conscious look at the environment and recording those feelings and events.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment